The ongoing Eliminator of the Indian Premier League (IPL) 2024 was marred by a massive controversy over Dinesh Karthik’s lbw call. The match between the Rajasthan Royals (RR) and the Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) is being played in Ahmedabad.
Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) keeper-batter Dinesh Karthik walked out to bat in the 15th over and he didn’t have the kind of first ball he would’ve wanted. The right-hander was struck on the pads and was given out by the on-field umpire.
However, Dinesh Karthik after discussing with his partner went up for the DRS. The keeper-batter played across the line to the ball that was full and straight, bending in late and hitting the pads. However, the UltraEdge showed that there was a big spike but from the first look, it was hard to figure out if that was off-bat hitting pad or the inside edge.
However, after a few replays, it was visible that Dinesh Karthik’s bat hit the pad before the ball came and after that, there was a big spike. The third umpire, however, didn’t notice it and made a blunder, considering the spike as a ball hitting the bat.
However, there was a massive gap between bat and ball and after that third umpire termed it not out, the entire Rajasthan Royals team went berserk. Even head coach Kumar Sangakkara moved from his dugout to have a chat with the fourth umpire.
Here’s the video of the dismissal:
Out or Not Out – what do you think? 👀#RRvRCB #IPLonJioCinema #TATAIPL #TATAIPLPlayoffs pic.twitter.com/o8Zn0TAUJJ
— JioCinema (@JioCinema) May 22, 2024
The third umpire’s decision didn’t go well with many as it even made commentators on-air think about the thought process behind the dismissal. Sunil Gavaskar was sure that the bat hit the pad and said: “The bat has hit the pad, the bat has not hit the ball”.
Kevin Pietersen also claimed that the third umpire didn’t get his decision right and stated: “I don’t think the umpire has got the decision right”.
Irfan Pathan, who was also doing commentary agreed on the fact that the third umpire didn’t make the correct decision. He said: “The ball does not touch the bat, this was not the right decision by the third Umpire”.
Fans on Twitter react as third umpire makes wrong decision on Dinesh Karthik’s lbw
As the third umpire made a poor call on Dinesh Karthik’s lbw in the ongoing Indian Premier League (IPL) 2024 game, fans on X were left angry. They lashed out at the third umpire for the poor call and also speculated about match-fixing. Here are some of the reactions:
There’s a reason why technology has been introduced in cricket – to make the right call. And I wonder why the third umpire is always in a hurry . That was clearly bat hitting the pad first . Was plumb infront IMO. #RRVSRCB
— Shreevats goswami (@shreevats1) May 22, 2024
It was a shocker .. these mistakes shouldn’t happen at this level .. https://t.co/lFmzZJ07HT
— Michael Vaughan (@MichaelVaughan) May 22, 2024
Bat hit pad, also DK looked hesitant to review as he knew he was out. Third umpire got it wrong again. #RCBvRR #Eliminator #IPL2024 pic.twitter.com/psudjyMqbv
— Wasim Jaffer (@WasimJaffer14) May 22, 2024
That was clear out. Even Dinesh Karthik knew it. Another umpiring blunder in this IPL. pic.twitter.com/S16lWFUxAG
— R A T N I S H (@LoyalSachinFan) May 22, 2024
Dinesh Karthik was definitely out #RCBvsRR
— Vikrant Gupta (@vikrantgupta73) May 22, 2024
Ache se zoom karke dekhlo kahi bhi ball nahi laga batt pe.
Clearly fixing by haarcb
Guys dinesh karthik chala gaya tha pehle hi.
Fixing se review lene lagaya. pic.twitter.com/X7Gy9r2ipD
— The Failed engineer 🇵🇸 (@you_fade7_away) May 22, 2024
That was clear out. Even Dinesh Karthik new it 😂🤣 pic.twitter.com/fcktOT10lf
— Yash Godara(KKR KA PARIVAR) (@105of70Mumbai) May 22, 2024
Dinesh Karthik was out LBW first ball. It was a plumb. The TV umpire gave a shockingly wrong decision.
Happens. There is little option but to move on. 🙂
— Abhishek Mukherjee (@ovshake42) May 22, 2024
Is Dinesh Karthik OUT or NOT OUT ?
What’s your take on this 🤔 #RCBvsRR pic.twitter.com/vESCDuupvY
— Richard Kettleborough (@RichKettle07) May 22, 2024
#RCBvsRR
That was clear out , commentators, RCB , RR fans even Dinesh Karthik knew that but these cheaters try to win this match like previous 6 matches pic.twitter.com/FHglUICaEL
— theboysthing_ (@Theboysthing) May 22, 2024
Man I just saw Dinesh Karthik was clearly out but now Haarcb buying umpires to win the match 😭
— Dev 🇮🇳 (@time__square) May 22, 2024
Clear fixing by haarcb, umprires are performing better than Maxwell and chokli for them still the chokers will choke #RCBvsRR #dineshkarthik pic.twitter.com/eV49g6IDea
— U M A R (@Agrumpycomedian) May 22, 2024
Dinesh Karthik was himself almost convinced that he is OUT but third Umpire had other plans. 😂
— Cric Point (@RealCricPoint) May 22, 2024
Leave feedback about this